Hoarding Disorder: Understanding the Causes and Impact on Mental Health

https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/young-man-isolation-home_19333094.htm#fromView=search&page=1&position=0&uuid=8856f0cc-c30f-4236-86a3-806bcb87b32c

Hoarding disorder, often simply referred to as hoarding, is a complex mental health condition characterized by an overwhelming difficulty in discarding or parting with possessions, regardless of their actual value. This behavior is not merely a quirky habit or a sign of laziness; it is a serious psychological issue that can significantly impair an individual's quality of life and affect those around them. Individuals with hoarding disorder often experience intense anxiety and distress at the thought of discarding items, leading to the accumulation of clutter that can overwhelm their living spaces. This article aims to delve deeper into the causes, symptoms, impacts, and potential coping strategies for hoarding disorder, with a particular focus on case examples from Indonesia.

Causes of Hoarding Disorder

https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/young-woman-dealing-with-anxiety_29310089.htm#fromView=search&page=1&position=14&uuid=97f8d0bb-6725-44ff-8753-aa62da7a92c8

The etiology of hoarding disorder is multifaceted and can vary widely among individuals. Understanding these causes is crucial for effective intervention and support. Here are some of the primary factors that contribute to the development of hoarding disorder:

Psychological Factors: Many individuals with hoarding disorder have a history of other mental health issues, such as anxiety disorders, depression, or obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). For some, hoarding may serve as a coping mechanism to manage feelings of anxiety, helplessness, or low self-esteem. The act of holding onto items can provide a false sense of security and control in an otherwise chaotic emotional landscape.

Traumatic Experiences: Traumatic life events, such as the death of a loved one, divorce, or experiencing a natural disaster, can trigger hoarding behaviors. In these cases, the items that are hoarded may serve as tangible reminders of the trauma, leading individuals to believe that discarding these items would mean losing a part of their past or their connection to the event.

Difficulty in Decision Making: Individuals with hoarding disorder often struggle with decision-making, particularly when it comes to determining what to keep and what to discard. This indecisiveness can stem from a fear of making the wrong choice, leading to the accumulation of unnecessary items. The inability to make these decisions can create a cycle of clutter that becomes increasingly difficult to manage.

Genetic Factors: Research suggests that hoarding disorder may have a genetic component. Studies have indicated that individuals with a family history of hoarding are more likely to develop the disorder themselves. This genetic predisposition may interact with environmental factors, further complicating the development of hoarding behaviors.

Cognitive Distortions: Many individuals with hoarding disorder exhibit cognitive distortions, such as overestimating the value of their possessions or believing that they will need an item in the future. These distorted thought patterns can reinforce the behavior of hoarding and make it challenging to let go of items.

Symptoms of Hoarding Disorder

Recognizing the symptoms of hoarding disorder is essential for understanding the severity of the condition. The following are common symptoms associated with hoarding disorder:

Excessive Accumulation of Items: Individuals with hoarding disorder often accumulate a large number of items, to the point where their living spaces become cluttered and unmanageable. This accumulation can include anything from newspapers and magazines to clothing, food containers, and other household items.

Difficulty Discarding Items: One of the hallmark symptoms of hoarding disorder is the profound difficulty individuals experience when attempting to throw away or donate items. They may feel an intense emotional attachment to their possessions, leading to feelings of loss or grief when considering discarding them.

Disorganization and Messiness: The excessive accumulation of items often results in disorganized and messy living spaces. Individuals may struggle to find essential items, and their homes may become hazardous due to clutter, creating risks for fire, pest infestations, and other health issues.

Anxiety About Future Needs: Individuals with hoarding disorder often experience anxiety about the possibility of needing an item in the future. This fear can lead to the retention of items that may seem insignificant to others, further contributing to the clutter.

Social Isolation: Many individuals with hoarding disorder feel embarrassed or ashamed of their living conditions, leading to social withdrawal and isolation. They may avoid inviting friends or family over, which can exacerbate feelings of loneliness and depression.

Forbid others from cleaning their house : Individuals who experience hoarding disorder tend to lock themselves in their room or house and will not allow others to enter their house or room. This is because individuals who experience hoarding disorder, if others clean their belongings, then they will feel like they have lost their belongings.

Distancing themselves from family and friends : Individuals who experience hoarding disorder will feel ashamed of their surroundings, such as friends and family, which is why individuals who experience hoarding disorder will withdraw from their social environment. Hoarding disorder behaviour also provides a negative view from people around them so that individuals who experience hoarding disorder feel ashamed of their condition.

The Impact of Hoarding Disorder on Mental Health

Hoarding disorder can have profound effects on an individual's mental health and overall well-being. The following are some of the significant impacts associated with the disorder:

Social Isolation: The shame and embarrassment associated with hoarding can lead individuals to isolate themselves from friends and family. This social withdrawal can result in a lack of support and connection, further exacerbating feelings of loneliness and depression.

Depression and Anxiety: The cycle of hoarding can contribute to worsening mental health conditions, including depression and anxiety. Individuals may feel trapped in their behavior, leading to feelings of hopelessness and despair. The clutter can serve as a constant reminder of their struggles, making it difficult to find relief or escape from their situation.

Stigma and Misunderstanding: Society often misunderstands hoarding disorder, viewing it as a mere quirk or a sign of laziness. This stigma can prevent individuals from seeking help, as they may fear judgment or ridicule. The lack of understanding can also lead to strained relationships with family and friends, who may not know how to support their loved ones effectively.

Physical Health Risks: The accumulation of items can create unsafe living conditions, leading to physical health risks. Clutter can obstruct pathways, increase the risk of falls, and create fire hazards. Additionally, hoarding can lead to unsanitary conditions, attracting pests and contributing to respiratory issues or other health problems.

Impact on Daily Functioning: Hoarding disorder can interfere with an individual's ability to perform daily tasks, such as cleaning, cooking, or even sleeping. The overwhelming clutter can make it challenging to maintain a functional living environment, leading to increased stress and frustration.

Case Study in Indonesia

In Indonesia, hoarding disorder is often observed in various contexts, including among residents of boarding houses. A notable case in Bekasi highlights the challenges faced by individuals with hoarding disorder. A viral video depicted a boarding house resident who had fallen behind on rent payments. When the boarding house owner entered the room to assess the situation, they discovered an overwhelming amount of plastic waste and other items that had accumulated over time. The door was difficult to open due to the sheer volume of clutter, which included food wrappers, empty bottles, and discarded boxes.

This case illustrates the profound impact of hoarding disorder on daily life. The resident's social isolation was evident, as they rarely interacted with other boarding house residents. The owner’s shock and discomfort upon discovering the state of the room created tension between them, highlighting the strain that hoarding can place on relationships. This situation serves as a reminder of the importance of understanding and addressing hoarding disorder within the community.

Another case occurred with Caesar Hito, an Indonesian actor, who revealed that he had experienced a hoarding disorder which started from psychological stress and mental problems. Hito explained that feelings of anxiety and insecurity in his life drove him to collect excessive items, which eventually became a habit that was difficult to control. He realised that hoarding disorder was not just a matter of habit but was also closely related to his emotional and psychological condition.

In his recovery process, Hito received help from a therapist who helped him understand the root of the problem and overcome his anxiety. Hito shared his experience to raise awareness of the importance of mental health, as well as to invite people to be more sensitive to this kind of psychological disorder, which is often underestimated. He hopes that by talking openly about his problems, people can more easily seek help if they experience something similar.

How to Cope with Hoarding Disorder

https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/funny-young-woman-20s-casual-clothes-isolated-pink-background-studio-portrait-love-concept-shows-heart-with-hands_13164246.htm#fromView=search&page=1&position=34&uuid=a154e238-1df6-449e-a162-606e16303eb0

Coping with hoarding disorder requires a multifaceted approach that often involves professional help, social support, and personal commitment. Here are some strategies that can be effective in managing hoarding behaviors:

Seeking Professional Help: Engaging with a mental health professional who specializes in hoarding disorder can be a crucial step toward recovery. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) is one effective treatment method that helps individuals identify and change the thought patterns that contribute to hoarding behavior. Therapists can provide guidance and support throughout the process of decluttering and addressing underlying emotional issues.

Building a Support Network: Establishing a strong support network of family and friends can help individuals feel less isolated. Loved ones can provide emotional support, encouragement, and practical assistance in the decluttering process. Open communication about the challenges of hoarding can foster understanding and compassion.

Education and Awareness: Raising awareness about hoarding disorder within the community can help reduce stigma and promote understanding. Educational initiatives can inform individuals about the nature of the disorder, encouraging those affected to seek help without fear of judgment.

Gradual Decluttering: Tackling hoarding disorder often requires a gradual approach. Individuals can start by identifying specific areas of their living space that are most problematic and work on decluttering those spaces first. Setting small, achievable goals can make the process feel less overwhelming and more manageable.

Developing Coping Strategies: Learning stress management techniques can be beneficial for individuals with hoarding disorder. Practices such as mindfulness, meditation, and relaxation exercises can help reduce anxiety and improve emotional regulation. Engaging in regular physical activity can also contribute to overall well-being.

Creating a Plan for Future Items: Developing a plan for how to handle new items can help prevent future hoarding behaviors. Individuals can establish guidelines for what to keep and what to discard, making it easier to manage possessions moving forward.

Challenges in Treatment

1. Difficulty Recognizing the Problem

Many people with hoarding disorder do not consider their behaviour to be a problem. They are very attached to the items they collect and often feel that they have value or significance, even though they may not be to others. This makes them reluctant to seek help or accept that their behaviour needs to change.

2. Strong Emotional Attachment to Items

People with hoarding disorder often feel a very strong emotional attachment to their belongings. Even though the items may seem useless to others, they may feel anxious or afraid to let go or throw them away. This feeling can be very difficult and is one of the biggest obstacles to treatment.

3. Negative Reactions from Family and Environment

Family or friends often feel frustrated and confused when faced with hoarding behaviour. They may not know how to provide appropriate support and can be upset by the messy condition of the house. This reaction can sometimes make things worse and make the sufferer feel more withdrawn or reluctant to accept help.

4. Time-consuming treatment

Overcoming hoarding disorder takes a long time. Changing thought patterns and habits that have formed over the years cannot be changed overnight. Therapy, especially cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT), requires a very gradual approach, which can sometimes be frustrating for sufferers. They must learn to change the way they think about their belongings and begin to let go of their attachments.

5. Other Mental Health Conditions

Many people with hoarding disorder also experience other mental health problems, such as anxiety, depression, or obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). The presence of these other conditions makes treatment more complicated, as it must address multiple interrelated psychological issues. Therefore, hoarding treatment often requires a more comprehensive approach and collaboration between multiple professionals.

6. Changing a Cluttered Environment

Changing a home environment that is overcrowded with stuff is a very difficult process for people with hoarding disorder. They may feel like they have lost a part of themselves or feel insecure after the things they consider important are thrown away. Therefore, this process requires a very sensitive and understanding approach so that the sufferer does not feel forced or pressured.

Conclusion

Hoarding disorder is a complex and challenging mental health condition that can significantly impact an individual's quality of life and the lives of those around them. Understanding the causes, symptoms, and effects of hoarding disorder is essential for fostering empathy and support for those affected. By raising awareness, providing education, and encouraging individuals to seek professional help, we can work toward reducing the stigma associated with hoarding disorder and promoting healthier coping strategies. With the right support and interventions, individuals can learn to manage their hoarding behaviors and improve their overall quality of life.

References

American Psychiatric Association. (2013). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (5th ed.). Arlington, VA: American Psychiatric Publishing.

Frost, R. O., & Steketee, G. (2010). Stuff: Compulsive hoarding and the meaning of things. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt.

hotdetik.com, “Caesar Hito pernah alami hoarding disorder bermula dari psikis dan mental”, https://hot.detik.com/celeb/d-7600060/caesar-hito-pernah-alami-hoarding-disorder-bermula-dari-psikis-dan-mental

detik.com, 17 Juli 2024,”Penghuni yang Viral Digerebek Ibu Kos Diduga Idap Hoarding Disorder, Apa Itu?”, https://www.detik.com/properti/berita/d-7443421/penghuni-yang-viral-digerebek-ibu-kos-diduga-idap-hoarding-disorder-apa-itu

alodokter.com, “Hoarding disorder”, https://www.alodokter.com/hoarding-disorder

International OCD Foundation. (n.d.).